strategy-compare
marketcalls/vectorbt-backtesting-skills
Compare multiple trading strategies side-by-side with performance metrics and equity curves.
What is strategy-compare?
Backtests and compares multiple trading strategies (long, short, or both) on the same stock symbol using OpenAlgo indicators. Generates a comparison table with key metrics like Sharpe ratio, max drawdown, and win rate, plus overlaid equity curve plots.
- Fetch historical data via OpenAlgo or DuckDB
- Run multiple strategies (EMA crossover, RSI, Donchian, Supertrend) on identical data
- Generate side-by-side performance metrics table with Sharpe, Sortino, max drawdown, win rate, and profit factor
- Include NIFTY benchmark comparison in results
- Plot overlaid equity curves for all strategies using Plotly
- Export comparison results to CSV
How to install strategy-compare
npx skills add https://github.com/marketcalls/vectorbt-backtesting-skills --skill strategy-compare- OpenAlgo installed and configured (or DuckDB path with pre-loaded data)
- Python environment with vectorbt, pandas, plotly
- Historical OHLCV data for the target symbol
How to use strategy-compare
- 1.Run the skill with a symbol and strategy names: `/strategy-compare RELIANCE ema-crossover rsi donchian`
- 2.If no strategies specified, defaults to comparing: ema-crossover, rsi, donchian, supertrend
- 3.Use `long-vs-short` flag to compare long-only vs short-only vs both directions
- 4.Review the generated comparison table showing metrics for each strategy vs NIFTY benchmark
- 5.Examine the Plotly equity curve plot to visualize strategy performance over time
- 6.Check the exported CSV file in `backtesting/strategy_comparison/` for detailed results
Use cases
- Compare which technical indicator strategy performs best on a specific stock
- Evaluate long vs short trading performance on the same symbol
- Benchmark your strategy against NIFTY index returns
- Analyze strategy robustness across different market conditions
- Select the highest Sharpe ratio strategy before live trading
- Quantitative traders evaluating multiple strategies
- Retail investors backtesting technical indicators
- Algo traders optimizing strategy selection
- Financial analysts comparing trading approaches
strategy-compare FAQ
EMA crossover, RSI, Donchian, and Supertrend by default. The skill uses OpenAlgo ta library for all indicators, with TA-Lib only if explicitly requested.
Yes. Include 'long-vs-short' in your strategy list to compare long-only, short-only, and both directions for the first strategy.
Yes. The comparison table automatically includes NIFTY index performance (via OpenAlgo NSE_INDEX) alongside your strategy metrics.
For Indian delivery equity, the skill applies 0.00111 (0.111%) proportional fees plus ₹20 fixed fees per trade.
Yes. Provide a DuckDB path and the skill will load data directly instead of fetching from OpenAlgo.
Full instructions (SKILL.md)
Source of truth, from marketcalls/vectorbt-backtesting-skills.
name: strategy-compare description: Compare multiple strategies or directions (long vs short vs both) on the same symbol. Generates side-by-side stats table. argument-hint: "[symbol] [strategies...]" allowed-tools: Read, Write, Edit, Bash, Glob, Grep
Create a strategy comparison script.
Arguments
Parse $ARGUMENTS as: symbol followed by strategy names
$0= symbol (e.g., SBIN, RELIANCE, NIFTY)- Remaining args = strategies to compare (e.g., ema-crossover rsi donchian)
If only a symbol is given with no strategies, compare: ema-crossover, rsi, donchian, supertrend. If "long-vs-short" is one of the strategies, compare longonly vs shortonly vs both for the first real strategy.
Instructions
- Read the vectorbt-expert skill rules for reference patterns
- Create
backtesting/strategy_comparison/directory if it doesn't exist (on-demand) - Create a
.pyfile inbacktesting/strategy_comparison/named{symbol}_strategy_comparison.py - The script must:
- Fetch data once via OpenAlgo
- If user provides a DuckDB path, load data directly via
duckdb.connect(path, read_only=True). See vectorbt-expertrules/duckdb-data.md. - If
openalgo.tais not importable (standalone DuckDB), use inlineexrem()fallback. - Use OpenAlgo ta for ALL indicators by default (never VectorBT built-in). Only switch to TA-Lib if the user explicitly says "talib"/"TA-Lib"
- Always use OpenAlgo ta for specialty indicators (Supertrend, Donchian, etc.) - no TA-Lib equivalent exists
- Clean signals with
ta.exrem()(always.fillna(False)before exrem) - Run each strategy on the same data
- Indian delivery fees:
fees=0.00111, fixed_fees=20for delivery equity - Collect key metrics from each into a side-by-side DataFrame
- Include NIFTY benchmark in the comparison table (via OpenAlgo
NSE_INDEX) - Print Strategy vs Benchmark comparison table: Total Return, Sharpe, Sortino, Max DD, Win Rate, Trades, Profit Factor
- Explain results in plain language - which strategy performed best and why
- Plot overlaid equity curves for all strategies using Plotly (
template="plotly_dark") - Save comparison to CSV
- Never use icons/emojis in code or logger output
Example Usage
/strategy-compare RELIANCE ema-crossover rsi donchian
/strategy-compare SBIN long-vs-short ema-crossover
Related skills
More from marketcalls/vectorbt-backtesting-skills and the wider catalog.


